Is The Legal Health-Care “Plan” in Order?
Updated: Jun 29, 2021
End-of-Life Legal Planning and the Terri Schiavo Case
Many rightly go to great lengths to ensure that their retirement plans are in order. However, it is less common to adequately plan for the significant health-care legal issues which are almost certain to come – such as the decision to continue or remove life support. This situation was brought into public focus in the well-known Terri Schiavo saga.
In early 1990, Teresa “Terri” Schiavo collapsed in her St. Petersburg apartment. Mrs. Schiavo’s husband, Michael, called 911 and paramedics found her unresponsive. At the hospital Terri was placed on a ventilator and was diagnosed as being in a persistent vegetative state. At that time Terri had no health-care legal documentation in place – and thus a tumultuous legal battle ensued between Terri’s parents and Michael.
Over the years witnesses provided varying testimony regarding Terri’s end-of-life wishes, with Michael asserting that she would not want life support, and Terri’s parents countering that she was a devout Catholic and thus would desire life support. All told, more than a decade passed and hundreds of thousands of dollars were spent for the various court actions. Ultimately, in 2005, Terri was disconnected from life support.
Fortunately, for those who properly plan, the Schiavo situation can be easily avoided.
Under Florida statute 765.302, any person age 18 or over may execute a “Living Will.” In the Living Will the person directs either that life support be continued or removed once the statutory medical criteria for life support removal are met. Importantly, Florida statutes provide that a Living Will constitutes “clear and convincing evidence” of the patient’s health-care wishes, and therefore one’s directives in the Living Will are to be carried out regardless of contentious parties.
However, if there is no health-care documentation, the decision to continue or to remove life support passes to the patient’s “Statutory Proxy.” The general statutory sequence for the Proxy appointment is first the spouse, then one’s adult children, then one’s parents, then one’s siblings, and finally a “close friend.”
Importantly, as in the Schiavo case, the Statutory Proxy may not have life support removed unless it is shown by “clear and convincing evidence” that removal would have been the patient’s desire. Consequently, if there is substantial evidence that the patient may have desired life support, then life support may not be removed.
Further, if there is no evidence regarding the patient’s life support desire, then life support may only be removed if removal is deemed to be in the patient’s “best interest” – but the Florida statutes do not define what is one’s “best interest.”
In addition to the Living Will, a properly-crafted health-care plan will also contain a Health Care Surrogate designation. In this designation the patient identifies the person who will serve as Surrogate – in lieu of the Statutory Proxy – if the patient becomes incapacitated. The Surrogate holds legal authority to act on behalf of the patient in all health-care matters but must follow any specific instructions in the Living Will.
It is critical that one execute a Surrogate designation so that the hand-picked Surrogate will be positioned to make medical decisions if incapacity occurs. Importantly, the Surrogate designation precludes the appointment of the Statutory Proxy – who may be a person ill-suited for this role – such as an estranged adult child.
For those persons with existing health-care plans, it is advisable that the plan be reviewed whenever there has been a significant change in one’s circumstances – such as a move to another state. And even if no significant change of circumstances has occurred, a good rule of thumb is to “re-sign” the health-care plan every 5 years. This is because such health-care documents remain valid indefinitely but Florida law authorizes these documents to be verbally revoked by the patient – and thus presenting an “old” Living Will to a medical facility may raise the question as to whether the now incapacitated patient had verbally revoked the document.
And health-care planning is not just for seniors. It should be recalled that Terri Schiavo was only 26 years old when her ordeal began. Therefore, I encourage clients to urge their adult children to take the short period of time required to implement their own health-care plans.
In summary, the “value” of a proper health-care plan can be enormous to one’s family – particularly at a very difficult time. Therefore, it is prudent to have a health-care plan prepared that is closely tailored to one’s wishes and compliant with Florida law. And although health organizations, websites and office supply shops often offer “fill in the blank” health-care documents, I recommend that such self-help shortcuts be avoided in these important matters.
Plan for Your Future
The Law Office of Robert H. Eardley, P.A. was founded to provide a broad spectrum of personalized trusts and estates legal counsel to the greater Southwest Florida community. Our legal team has decades of experience as well as the highest professional ratings to bring you comprehensive legal services tailored to meet your unique needs. Contact our Naples office today.
Robert H. Eardley, Esq., is Board Certified by the Florida Bar as a Wills, Trusts and Estates specialist, holds a Master of Laws (LL.M.) degree in Estate Planning, and practices law in Naples. He may be reached by telephone at (239) 591-6776 or by visiting the firm’s website at www.swflorida-law.com/contact.